Categories
Climate Adaptation, South Asia Innovation Integrated Water Resources Management Policy and Planning Regional

Interview with Kamal Kishore

Kamal Kishore, Member, National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), India, is also serving as the Indian Co-Chair of the Coalition for Disaster Resilient Infrastructure (CDRI). 

ADPC recently held an exclusive ‘Climate Talks’ discussion with this esteemed disaster risk and resilience expert on India’s efforts towards strengthening disaster and climate resilience.

https://youtu.be/A-A7mZFwKTI

Which natural hazards or climate-induced threats have the highest impacts in India?

Let me start with cyclones. We traditionally invest more in cyclone resilience for the eastern coast of India, but we’ve noticed increased cyclone activity on the western coast as well in the last 6 to 7 years. 

While we’re not yet sure that this is a long-lasting trend, it has an impact on our resources as we need to expand the same success against cyclones to both coastlines.

The same is the issue with flooding. There have been years when the overall monsoons performance in terms of All India Rainfall Index have been lower then normal, yet some parts of the country experienced extreme floods. 

We really have to focus on improving our flood risk management practices, early warning systems, flood control measures, and better land-use planning.

We also have “inter-connected mountain hazards” like glacial lake outbursts which lead to floods, landslides, avalanches, formation of lakes, and flash flooding downstream. 

We’re working towards coming up with an integrated approach for monitoring these hazards and taking steps to provide as best an early warning as we can and overall, strengthen systems at the community-level to respond to these warnings and take necessary action.

A lot of these hazards will impact our infrastructure, and India is a country which still has a large infrastructure deficit. 

This is why big investments are going into building the resilience of such projects for generations to come, and it is in this context that India has been working with 26 other countries and international organizations to create the Coalition for Disaster Resilient Infrastructure to advance resilient power systems, water systems, telecommunications, railways, and freight corridors to withstand future climates.

How effective is India in promoting disaster risk reduction?

We’ve had good success in saving more lives by connecting science to society and taking a multi-sectoral approach. For example, we’ve been able to reduce mortalities from heatwaves by 90 percent, but we need to go beyond and reduce other kinds of losses as well.

We have to save lives, but also livelihoods. That requires making our infrastructure services resilient to shocks from natural hazards. We are making sure that power systems don’t go down when cyclones hit or come back on quickly. 

There were times when power outages in cyclone-affected areas went on for months, but now some cities having underground cabling and better management systems, that recovery time has reduced to just a few days.

Can you share some experiences in managing disasters and climate change during COVID-19?

It’s been a challenging time! We’ve had five cyclones during the pandemic on the eastern and western coasts. 

The National Disaster Risk Force (NDRF) had to not only protect people affected by cyclones, but also themselves from health risks. Around 100 NDRF members tested positive, but luckily, they all recovered in good time.

Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) were redrafted, protective gear was distributed and evacuation procedures were revised to minimize the risk of transmission. Once vaccines were distributed, NDRF members were prioritized. 

One key lesson is that SOPs cannot be frozen in time, they need to continually evolve to respond to new risks that become known, otherwise they will become outdated and ineffective.

Given India’s high population, what are the roles of local governments and communities?

They shouldn’t only participate; they have to lead. Communities know how to respond to an early warning in an organized fashion.

When it comes to cyclone shelters, the story to be told is that these shelters are multi-purpose and they’re managed by communities themselves.

If the Government is the only one managing it, then it is very possible that the cyclone shelter is either not available or not in a good condition. 

If it is managed in the community as part of their daily lives, they will have their own organization around it to ensure that the needs of women, children, old people, etc., are properly met during evacuation.

How is the Government ensuring access to disaster risk financing?

The Finance Commission, constituted every five years, looks at how central revenues are distributed and one of its thematic areas is disaster risk management. 

From this Commission onwards, India has predictable finance that covers the entire spectrum of disaster risk management activities—there are resources allocated to response, recovery and preparedness and capacity building on the one hand, and mitigation on the other. 

The resources we have from these dedicated windows will be able to catalyze additional financing within the development sectors themselves. 

Turning policies into action is very challenging, however, so I hope that in a few years we can measure our success not by the amount of money we spent, but rather the outcomes we have achieved in risk reduction.

 

Kamal spoke to Ms. Vidya Rana, Senior Communications Manager, ADPC.

Categories
Gender Policy and Planning Regional

Enhancing Participation: Women and Resilience in the Face of Climate Change

Syeda Hadika Jamshaid, Climate Change Specialist at the Ministry of Climate Change (MoCC), Pakistan, is also currently serving as the UNFCCC Gender Focal Person for Pakistan. 

She supports the MoCC in building climate resilient infrastructure, towards achieving Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC), localizing carbon market tools for sustainable development, and mainstreaming gender into policies and programs.

What initiatives are Pakistan taking to make women and marginalized groups more resilient to climate change, which has been compounded by the COVID-19 pandemic?

Pakistan is implementing various initiatives that have tried to address gender-related issues, apart from mitigating climate change impacts. Examples include the following projects: 

We have started the Ten Billion Tree Tsunami Programme (TBTPP). This programme provides livelihood opportunities for women in forestry. 

It also assists women with raising plant nurseries in rural areas. Importantly, it employs female community mobilization teams of the Forest Department; which would approach those women who are impoverished and destitute, and then educate and train them.

Another initiative is the Prime Minister’s Green Stimulus package which is targeted at COVID-idled daily wagers, including women, and largely focuses on diverting and re-configuring components of TBTTP to plant trees, raise saplings, and protect the plantations from intruders.

Clean Green Pakistan Movement (CGPM) was re-designed post-COVID to assist with the objectives of job creation, by contributing to total sanitation, solid waste management, and hygiene within identified districts of two provinces (Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa). 

This movement was redesigned to target a total of 53,250 livelihood opportunities over the span of three months. 

This would include community and, social mobilizers raising awareness around sanitation and drain cleaning, garbage collectors/scavengers, as well as certified Clean Green Champions. 

After the success of the pilot phase, the movement has been scaled up to include Azad Jammu Kashmir and Gilgit Baltistan.

I would also like to mention Glacial Lake Outburst Flood (GLOF) risk reduction in Northern Pakistan which aims at building resilience through Early Warning Systems (EWS), infrastructure, and disaster management policies. 

Project planning involved gender assessment: it aims to ensure enhanced participation of women. 

All the above-mentioned adaptation measures are created with the intention of building community resilience by means of enhancing the participation of women. 

Besides, with a view to narrowing gender gaps and integrating gender perspectives in all sectoral policies, plans and strategies, the National Climate Change Gender Action Plan (ccGAP) is currently being drafted by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) and Pakistan in coordination with the Ministry of Climate Change (MoCC) and other relevant stakeholders.

You have been involved in the Intended Nationally Determined Contributions (INDC) process, which Pakistan has recently completed. 

Would you like to share how gender issues factor into the current INDC process?

As already highlighted, to make the updated NDC gender-sensitive, a Gender working group was formulated, which was led by a woman.

This Group would identify the gender gaps in NDC sectors and develop recommendations to close these gaps. The working group participated in various meetings and developed a working paper to inform the NDC about emerging priorities and challenges. 

However, women’s participation in the rest of the working groups was low, and in some cases even nil. I also noted that the gender representatives from provincial departments should have further been allowed to improve the recommendations but given the time constraints, the best possible outcome was delivered within the given time frame. 

We are hoping to fill this gap through the on-going ccGAP consultations.

The working groups organized a series of meetings to identify and consolidate Pakistan’s efforts over the last five years and to design recommendations for the next five years. 

The groups also identified the capacity, technology, and financial needs for NDC implementation. In addition to these, a few new areas were highlighted which were never a part of Pakistan’s NDC. 

These are youth, air pollution, health, WASH (Water, Sanitation and Hygiene), Blue Carbon, Carbon Markets, etc. 

Different sector partners helped the MoCC to develop evidence-based recommendations to enhance the NDC commitments. 

All these activities have been concluded, and NDC is now in the final stages of completion.

The Ministry of Climate Change has prepared a roadmap for the 26th iteration of the Conference of the Parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change 2021 (COP26); to systematically engage government agencies and other partners in the process. 

As a part of the roadmap, thematic committees have also been constituted. Could you please tell us how gender has been mainstreamed into these committees? 

What are the achievements of the working group on gender and women’s issues?

Two technical working groups were created, namely, adaptation and mitigation. 

Both groups had subgroups based on NDC sectors like waste, land use change, agriculture, industry, energy, etc. 

It was ensured that provincial focal points are also a part of the groups in addition to participation from government sector, private sector, development sector partners, academia, private think tanks and community-based organizations. 

Gender, as the crosscutting issue, had its own working group to ensure the recommendations are gender sensitive.

Pakistan will have its own pavilion at COP26, with side events, for which necessary arrangements have been made.

Could you identify gaps and challenges, with reference to gender considerations in climate resilience in Pakistan?

First and foremost is the inconsistency in the efforts that have been made so far. To sustain inclusive climate-resilient programming and operations,

We need policies which necessitate all programs to be gender-sensitive.

We have seen such approaches adopted at different levels in certain NGOs and in the commercial sector.

The development of gender indicators and markers will ensure gender-sensitive public programming.

Secondly, I would like to highlight that the biggest challenge in South Asian countries is the unavailability of sex-disaggregated data. 

Countries need to build capacities and human resources at the local level to collect and maintain this data on a regular basis, so as to understand and build evidence on the gendered impacts of climate change and to design climate informed-programs.

 

Jamshaid spoke to Bhawana Upadhay, Senior Specialist, Gender and Inclusion, ADPC.